Who Killed Eddie O’Hare? A True Crime Chicago History Mystery WHAT: Nitti’s Supper Club PRESENTS Who Killed Eddie O’Hare— A True Crime History Mystery WHERE: Harry Caray’s Italian Steakhouse, Lombard, IL WHEN: Friday, April 4 @ 7p Saturday, April 5 @ 6p Nitti’s Supper Club has been delivering an unforgettable dinner theater experience at Harry Caray’s Italian Steakhouse in River North since 2022, earning glowing reviews from guests from around the world. On April 4th and 5th, the show will take its act on the road to Harry Caray’s Lombard in the western suburbs. Inspired by real life events, Nitti’s Supper Club transports guests back to the era of Chicago’s notorious mobsters for an evening of delicious dining and interactive entertainment. Set against the backdrop of Frank Nitti’s birthday celebration, the show invites guests to uncover the mystery behind the real-life, unsolved murder of Edward J. "Easy Eddie" O’Hare—Al Capone’s lawyer and father of war hero Butch O’Hare for whom O’Hare Airport is named. Adding to the intrigue, Harry Caray’s flagship building in River North was once home to two of the main characters, Frank Nitti and his wife Annette, both of whom were key suspects in the murder. Guests will enjoy a three-course dinner while becoming part of the action, mingling with characters and piecing together clues in a setting that brings Chicago’s Prohibition-era past to life. With an ensemble cast of colorful characters, a fast-paced storyline and toe-tapping musical numbers, this irreverent comedy promises a night of laughs and surprises. Tickets, which include dinner and the show, are $80/guest. Advance reservations are required and can be made on our website.